Can't believe I never picked up on this thread. By far, the first Jaws is the best. I don't remember much of the others, besides watching them all as a kid. I have to have a Jaws marathon this summer soon.
I listened up to a little bit into the Skeleton Crew's review of Jaws 2 so far. Good stuff. Your nitpicks were hilarious. I have to look out for the beach towels next time I watch.